Reference catalogs · instrument
Beam Deflection — Overhanging Beam
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
Ledger state
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
- Area
- Mechanical, Civil & Structural Engineering — Statics/Dynamics, Strength of Materials, Machine Design, Civil, HVAC, Vibration
- Tranche
- tranche-6
- Evidence ID
- t6-024
- Ledger rows
- 1
No ledger note is attached.
Review findings
NEEDS_REVIEW because the specification does not uniquely define the support conditions, load model, sign conventions, or numeric-integration algorithm. The four deterministic benchmarks assume a simply supported beam with a free overhang, downward point loads, and exact Euler–Bernoulli/Macaulay calculations. A production implementation needs those assumptions exposed or explicitly fixed, plus validation of the numerical integration method against these closed-form results.
Formula and scope findings
- The stated formula, "Superposition of simple-span and cantilever-overhang equations," is not sufficiently specific to verify. Reactions, V(x), M(x), and deflection depend on the exact support topology; the vectors below assume simple supports at x=0 and x=L, with a free overhang from x=L to x=L+a.
- For arbitrary load positions, deflection must satisfy compatibility conditions δ(0)=δ(L)=0 and requires a fully specified Euler–Bernoulli/Macaulay or equivalent influence-function equation. Separate simple-span and cantilever formulas can be superposed only when their equivalent reactions and boundary conditions are handled consistently.
- The numeric-integration engine is unspecified: no integration method, step size, interpolation rule, or convergence tolerance is given. The benchmark vectors therefore use the exact closed-form point-load solution rather than an unspecified numerical integrator.
- Load types are ambiguous: "loads/positions" does not state whether loads may be point forces, distributed loads, moments, or combinations. The supplied formula is not sufficient for distributed loads or applied couples.
- The sign convention for reactions, shear, moment, and deflection is missing. The vectors use upward reactions positive, sagging moment positive, and downward deflection positive.
- No stated constraints prevent supports from coinciding, L<=0, negative overhang length, loads outside 0<=x<=L+a, E<=0, or I<=0.
Unit assumptions
- All quantities in each vector use one consistent unit system.
- For SI vectors, length is in m, force in N, E in Pa=N/m^2, I in m^4, moment in N·m, and deflection in m.
- For the millimetre vector, length is in mm, force is in N, E is in N/mm^2, I is in mm^4, moment is in N·mm, and deflection is in mm.
- Euler–Bernoulli small-deflection, linear-elastic beam theory is assumed; shear deformation and geometric nonlinearity are neglected.
- Assumed geometry is a simply supported beam at x=0 and x=L with a free overhang to x=L+a.
- For downward point loads P_i at z_i, R2=sum(P_i z_i)/L and R1=sum(P_i)-R2. With Macaulay brackets <q>^3=0 for q<0 and q^3 otherwise, M(x)=R1 x-sum(P_i<x-z_i>), and downward-positive deflection is δ(x)=-(R1 x^3/6-sum(P_i<x-z_i>^3/6+C x)/(E I)), where C=(-R1 L^3/6+sum(P_i<L-z_i>^3/6))/L.
Boundary hardening
BREAK_CLAIMED · SELF_FLAGGED
The instrument must reject I=0 because deflection formulas divide by E*I=0. It also risks incorrect signed results unless load direction, reaction signs, and deflection-positive direction are explicitly defined.
Errata and corrections
Tranche errata
delta at overhang tip · vector 1,3
+0.0777778 / +0.0669643
-0.0666667 / -0.0595238 (0.0667/0.0595 downward)
Macaulay integration omits the R2*<x-L>^3/6 term when evaluating beyond the right support; confirmed by numeric double integration and the standard P*a^2(L+a)/(3EI) formula
Inspectable example
4 review vectors are recorded. One source-bound sample is shown below.
{
"inputs": {
"model": "simple supports at x=0 and x=L; free overhang to x=L+a",
"L_m": 6,
"a_m": 2,
"point_loads": [
{
"P_N": 10000,
"z_m": 8
}
],
"E_Pa": 200000000000,
"I_m4": 0.000008,
"sample_x_m": [
0,
3,
6,
8
]
},
"expected_outputs": {
"R1_N": -3333.333333,
"R2_N": 13333.333333,
"V_N": {
"0<x<8": -3333.333333,
"8<x<8": "0 after the tip load; no beam interval beyond x=8"
},
"M_Nm": {
"x=0": 0,
"x=3": -10000,
"x=6": -20000,
"x=8": 0
},
"delta_downward_m": {
"x=0": 0,
"x=3": -0.028125,
"x=6": 0,
"x=8": 0.0777777778
},
"curve_features": {
"moment_roots_m": [
0,
8
],
"moment_extremum": {
"type": "minimum",
"x_m": 6,
"M_Nm": -20000
},
"deflection_support_roots_m": [
0,
6
],
"asymptotes": []
}
},
"working": "Equilibrium: R2=(10000*8)/6=13333.333333 N; R1=10000-13333.333333=-3333.333333 N. EI=200000000000*0.000008=1600000 N·m^2. For x<=6, M=R1*x, so M(3)=(-3333.333333)(3)=-10000 N·m and M(6)=(-3333.333333)(6)=-20000 N·m. For x=8, M=R1*8-10000*(8-8)=-26666.666664+26666.666664=0. The deflection constant is C=(-R1*6^3/6)/6=20000. At x=3, the bracket is R1*3^3/6+C*3=(-3333.333333*27/6)+60000=-15000+60000=45000; δ=-45000/1600000=-0.028125 m. At x=6, the bracket is (-3333.333333*216/6)+20000*6=-120000+120000=0; δ=0. At x=8, the bracket is (-3333.333333*512/6)+20000*8=-284444.4444+160000=-124444.4444; δ=124444.4444/1600000=0.0777777778 m. The shear is -3333.333333 N before the tip load and jumps by -10000 N at x=8."
}
Related workflows
No source-defined multi-instrument workflow membership is recorded.
Sources and evidence
These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.
VERIFIED_LEDGER.json · VERIFIED_WITH_ERRATAevidence-tranche6/tranche6-results.jsonBOUNDARY_HAZARD_CATALOG.json