Reference catalogs · instrument
Converging-Diverging Nozzle Area-Ratio Calculator
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
Ledger state
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
- Area
- Thermodynamics, Fluids & Aero
- Tranche
- tranche-6
- Evidence ID
- t6-085
- Ledger rows
- 1
No ledger note is attached.
Review findings
The core area-Mach formula is correct under the stated ideal 1D assumptions, but the instrument specification is incomplete for its claimed back-pressure-based regime output. Define Pb/P0, enforce Ae/A*>=1 and gamma>1, add the pressure and normal-shock algorithms, and distinguish formal branch roots from the actual unchoked operating Mach. The honest-label warning should explicitly state whether normal shocks and shock losses are modeled; otherwise 'shock-in-nozzle' is only a classification, not a physically computed solution.
Formula and scope findings
- The area-Mach relation is standard for quasi-one-dimensional, steady, adiabatic, isentropic flow with constant gamma, using A*=the sonic throat area. It is valid only for A/A* >= 1; this input constraint is not stated.
- The relation has two distinct roots only for A/A* > 1. At A/A*=1 the roots coalesce at M=1, so the claimed dual-root output needs an explicit boundary rule.
- The stated formula alone cannot determine the operating regime from back pressure. Shock-in-nozzle classification additionally requires the isentropic pressure relation, the choked-flow criterion, and normal-shock relations, including shock location or an equivalent pressure threshold algorithm.
- The back-pressure ratio is undefined. It must explicitly mean Pb/P0, where P0 is stagnation pressure upstream of the nozzle.
- For a shock-in-nozzle result, the model must include a normal shock and the associated total-pressure loss. Treating the entire nozzle as isentropic while reporting a shock-in-nozzle regime is inconsistent.
- The exit Mach solutions are independent of back pressure only after the nozzle is choked. For sufficiently high back pressure, the nozzle is unchoked and the supplied A/A* relation does not directly provide the actual exit Mach.
Unit assumptions
- gamma is dimensionless and is the constant ratio of specific heats; test cases use gamma=1.4 for air.
- Area ratio means the geometric exit-area-to-sonic-throat-area ratio Ae/A*.
- Back-pressure ratio means Pb/P0, with Pb static back pressure and P0 upstream stagnation pressure.
- Pressure ratios are dimensionless; no absolute pressure units are required.
- The ideal regime thresholds below assume a converging-diverging nozzle, ideal choking, isentropic regions away from a normal shock, and a normal shock when classified as shock-in-nozzle.
Boundary hardening
BREAK_CLAIMED · SELF_FLAGGED
The specified formula has an undefined gamma=1 input that requires explicit rejection, and the back-pressure ratio convention is not defined well enough to guarantee a unique operating-regime result.
Errata and corrections
Tranche errata
critical_choking_pressure_ratio_Pb_over_P0 · vector 1,2,3
0.528282
0.93716 for AR=2 (p at the subsonic-exit solution; per-AR for others)
ships the throat ratio (2/(g+1))^(g/(g-1)) as the choking BACK pressure — the classic misconception; a C-D nozzle chokes when Pb drops below the subsonic-branch exit pressure, not p*/P0 (v4 with AR=1 coincidentally agrees)
Inspectable example
4 review vectors are recorded. One source-bound sample is shown below.
{
"inputs": {
"area_ratio_A_over_Astar": 2,
"back_pressure_ratio_Pb_over_P0": 0.05,
"gamma": 1.4
},
"expected_outputs": {
"subsonic_M": 0.305904,
"supersonic_M": 2.1972,
"exit_supersonic_pressure_ratio_Pe_over_P0": 0.093934,
"critical_choking_pressure_ratio_Pb_over_P0": 0.528282,
"shock_at_exit_pressure_ratio_Pb_over_P0": 0.5135,
"operating_regime": "supersonic"
},
"working": "For gamma=1.4, A/A*=(1/M)[(5/6)(1+0.2M^2)]^3. Newton solve on g(M)=-ln(M)+3ln[(5/6)(1+0.2M^2)]-ln(2), with g'(M)=-1/M+1.2M/(1+0.2M^2). Subsonic branch: M0=0.300000; g(M0) is approximately +0.01738, g'(M0)=-2.97970, so M1=0.300000-(+0.01738)/(-2.97970)=0.305834. Second iteration gives M2 approximately 0.305904; subsequent iterations give M=0.305904. Supersonic branch: M0=2.00000; g(M0)=-0.169899, g'(M0)=0.833333, so M1=2.00000-(-0.169899)/(0.833333)=2.20388. Second iteration gives M2 approximately 2.19724; subsequent iterations give M=2.19720. Check: for M=2.19720, M^2=4.82768; (5/6)(1+0.2M^2)=(5/6)(1.965536)=1.637947; 1.637947^3/2.19720 approximately 2.00000. Exit pressure: Pe/P0=(1+0.2M^2)^(-gamma/(gamma-1))=1.965536^(-3.5)=0.093934. Choking limit: (2/(gamma+1))^(gamma/(gamma-1))=(5/6)^3.5=0.528282. Normal-shock pressure multiplier at M=2.19720 is 1+[2gamma/(gamma+1)](M^2-1)=1+(7/6)(3.82768)=5.46563; shock-at-exit Pb/P0=0.093934 times 5.46563 approximately 0.5135. Since Pb/P0=0.05 is below the design exit pressure ratio, the ideal flow is supersonic through the diverging section, with any adjustment shock outside the nozzle."
}
Related workflows
No source-defined multi-instrument workflow membership is recorded.
Sources and evidence
These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.
VERIFIED_LEDGER.json · VERIFIED_WITH_ERRATAevidence-tranche6/tranche6-results.jsonBOUNDARY_HAZARD_CATALOG.json