Reference catalogs · instrument
Derivative Calculator (symbolic + numeric)
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
Ledger state
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
- Area
- Mathematics — arithmetic through advanced (algebra, matrices, calculus, sequences/series, number theory, combinatorics, graphing, complex numbers, geometry, logic, sets)
- Tranche
- tranche-8
- Evidence ID
- t8-020
- Ledger rows
- 1
No ledger note is attached.
Review findings
The standard first-derivative formula is correct only when interpreted as (f(x+h)-f(x-h))/(2*h), with radians for trigonometric examples and a documented nonzero h. The specification is FAIL because h and the nth numeric-derivative algorithm are undefined, and the broad symbolic-support claim lacks domain and capability limits.
Formula and scope findings
- The numeric formula is written as f(x+h)-f(x-h)/2h, which is ambiguous under standard operator precedence; it must be explicitly written as (f(x+h)-f(x-h))/(2*h).
- The step size h is not specified as an input, fixed constant, adaptive value, or error-controlled value.
- Only the first-derivative central-difference formula is specified, but the instrument claims nth numeric derivatives; the algorithm for order greater than 1 is missing.
- The symbolic behavior and supported syntax/domain rules of math.js derivative() are not defined, so the claim of general symbolic differentiation is too broad.
- The numeric central difference is an approximation and should report or document its h-dependent numerical error.
Unit assumptions
- Angles are assumed to be in radians for trigonometric functions.
- The independent variable x and h must use the same units; h must be nonzero and sufficiently small relative to the scale of x.
- For logarithms and other restricted functions, inputs must remain in the function's valid real or complex domain.
- The displayed numeric values below use h=0.00001.
Boundary hardening
BREAK_CLAIMED · SELF_FLAGGED
The numeric path accepts h=0 unless it explicitly validates the step size; the central-difference formula then evaluates 0/0. The branch-switch probe also exposes a semantic hazard: abs(x) at x=0 yields a finite central estimate even though the true derivative is undefined.
Errata and corrections
Tranche errata
spot_checks[0] (at x=0) · vector 1
input_side=-0.9999999999
-1.9999999999 (matches answer_side=-2.0 to 10 decimals)
the numeric finite-difference at x=0 is off by almost exactly a factor of 2 from the correct derivative — consistent with dividing by h instead of 2h in the central-difference formula; the SAME vector's x=1 spot-check is computed correctly, so the error is local to this one point, not the whole method
Inspectable example
4 review vectors are recorded. One source-bound sample is shown below.
{
"inputs": {
"function": "x^3-2*x+1",
"variable": "x",
"point": 2,
"order": 1,
"h": 0.00001
},
"expected_outputs": {
"symbolic_derivative": "3*x^2-2",
"numeric_value": 10.0000000001,
"spot_checks": [
{
"at": 0,
"input_side": -0.9999999999,
"answer_side": -2
},
{
"at": 1,
"input_side": 1.0000000001,
"answer_side": 1
}
]
},
"reference_data": {
"method": "First-order central difference",
"h": 0.00001
},
"working": "Symbolic: d(x^3-2x+1)/dx = 3x^2-2; at x=2, 3(2^2)-2 = 12-2 = 10. Numeric: f(2.00001) = 2.00001^3 - 2(2.00001) + 1; f(1.99999) = 1.99999^3 - 2(1.99999) + 1. Their difference divided by 2(0.00001) simplifies exactly for this cubic to 3(2^2)-2+(0.00001)^2 = 10+0.0000000001 = 10.0000000001. At x=0, central result = -2+0.0000000001 = -1.9999999999? Correction: for f=x^3-2x+1, the central derivative is 3x^2-2+h^2. Thus at x=0 it is -1.9999999999, and at x=1 it is 1.0000000001. At x=2 it is 10.0000000001."
}
Related workflows
No source-defined multi-instrument workflow membership is recorded.
Sources and evidence
These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.
VERIFIED_LEDGER.json · VERIFIED_WITH_ERRATAevidence-tranche8/tranche8-results.jsonBOUNDARY_HAZARD_CATALOG.json