Reference catalogs · instrument
Three-Phase Power Calculator
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
Ledger state
The current ledger marks this instrument verified with errata that must be applied at binding time.
- Area
- Electrical & Electronics Engineering — Circuits, Power Systems, Electronics Lab
- Tranche
- tranche-4
- Evidence ID
- t4-042
- Ledger rows
- 1
No ledger note is attached.
Review findings
The current specification is incomplete for its claimed outputs and leaves the PF sign convention, RMS convention, and balanced-system scope unstated. The honest label should explicitly state that results apply to balanced three-phase RMS systems and that reactive-power sign requires a leading/lagging input.
Formula and scope findings
- P=√3·VL·IL·cosθ is correct for a balanced three-phase system using RMS line-to-line voltage, RMS line current, and power factor, but the spec does not state the balanced, sinusoidal, RMS assumptions.
- VL=√3·VPh is correct for a balanced wye connection only. For delta, VL=VPh; this required relationship is missing.
- The claimed Q output has no formula. For balanced operation, Q=√3·VL·IL·sinθ, but PF magnitude alone does not determine the sign of Q; leading versus lagging must be supplied.
- The claimed S output has no formula. For balanced operation, apparent power magnitude is S=√3·VL·IL.
- The claimed IL/IPh conversions are not specified. For wye, IL=IPh; for delta, IL=√3·IPh.
- The PF input is ambiguous: it must be identified as a magnitude with a separate leading/lagging indicator, or as a signed quantity. PF=cosθ alone is insufficient to determine reactive-power sign.
Unit assumptions
- VL and VPh are RMS volts; VL is line-to-line voltage and VPh is per-phase voltage.
- IL and IPh are RMS amperes; IL is line current and IPh is per-phase current.
- P and Q are watts and vars; S is volt-amperes.
- PF is dimensionless and represents the magnitude of displacement or true power factor, normally between 0 and 1; leading or lagging must be separately specified for Q sign.
- The formulas assume a balanced three-phase system. The listed voltage and current relationships assume standard wye or delta connections.
- Angles and trigonometric functions use degrees or radians consistently; the examples use PF directly and derive |sinθ|=√(1−PF²).
Boundary hardening
Recorded hazards
- Division by √3 is safe, but any inverse calculation such as current=power/(voltage·PF) requires explicit zero-voltage and zero-PF handling.
- PF values outside [0,1] are invalid if PF is an unsigned magnitude; the implementation must reject them or define signed-PF semantics.
- PF=0 makes calculations that divide by PF undefined, even though direct P, Q, and S calculations remain valid.
- Q sign is indeterminate unless leading or lagging behavior is provided; silently assuming lagging would produce misleading results.
- Unbalanced loads, non-sinusoidal waveforms, phase-to-neutral versus line-to-line voltage confusion, and peak-versus-RMS inputs can produce incorrect results.
- Connection type must be validated before applying wye/delta voltage and current conversions.
Errata and corrections
Tranche errata
S_VA, Q_var · vector 3
4782.860228
4780.4602
used √3≈1.7329 in S (her own Vph used the correct 1.73205)S_VA, Q_var · vector 4
S 3600, Q 2160
S 1800, Q 1080
S doubled; contradicts her own correct P=1440 at PF 0.8
Inspectable example
4 review vectors are recorded. One source-bound sample is shown below.
{
"inputs": {
"connection": "wye",
"VL_V": 400,
"IL_A": 10,
"PF": 0.8,
"reactive_behavior": "lagging"
},
"expected_outputs": {
"VPh_V": 230.940108,
"IPh_A": 10,
"P_W": 5542.562585,
"Q_var": 4156.921939,
"S_VA": 6928.20323
},
"working": "VPh=VL/√3=400/1.732050807=230.940108 V. For wye, IPh=IL=10 A. P=√3·VL·IL·PF=1.732050807·400·10·0.8=5542.562585 W. S=√3·VL·IL=1.732050807·400·10=6928.20323 VA. |sinθ|=√(1−0.8²)=√0.36=0.6; lagging gives positive Q, so Q=S·0.6=6928.20323·0.6=4156.921939 var."
}
Related workflows
No source-defined multi-instrument workflow membership is recorded.
Sources and evidence
These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.
VERIFIED_LEDGER.json · VERIFIED_WITH_ERRATAevidence-tranche4/tranche4-results.json